Rotten Tomatoes
Cancel Movies Tv shows RT App News Showtimes
Critics list

Esme Mazzeo

Esme Mazzeo's reviews only count toward the Tomatometer® when published at Tomatometer-approved publication(s).
Publications:

Reviews

Movies TV Shows
No Sleep 'Til Christmas (2018) 3.5/5 EDIT “No Sleep 'Til Christmas is definitely worth your time. Especially if Christmas movies aren't usually your cup of cocoa, so to speak.” – Tell-Tale TV Feb 11, 2023 Full Review One Summer (2021) 3.25/5 EDIT “One Summer's soundtrack is phenomenal and its cast is too good for its script.” – Tell-Tale TV Oct 7, 2021 Full Review The Christmas Setup (2020) 4.5/5 EDIT “Lifetime's The Christmas Setup does more than finally provide the LBGTQIA community representation in the beloved genre of TV Christmas movies. It does so in the most authentic way possible.” – Tell-Tale TV Dec 15, 2020 Full Review A Sugar & Spice Holiday (2020) 2.5/5 EDIT “A Sugar & Spice Holiday makes a good effort, but much like young Suzy's gingerbread house in the first scene, the script is not structurally sound.” – Tell-Tale TV Dec 15, 2020 Full Review The Christmas House (2020) 4.25/5 EDIT “The Christmas House proves that small details go a long way in telling a Christmas romance story, and hopefully, this is just the first step of many where representation is concerned.” – Tell-Tale TV Nov 23, 2020 Full Review Christmas in Vienna (2020) 3.25/5 EDIT “Opposites might attract, but Jess deserves someone more exciting than Mark. Drew and Elliot have just enough chemistry to carry the film, but it's nothing we can feel through the screen.” – Tell-Tale TV Nov 16, 2020 Full Review Holidate (2020) 45% 4/5 EDIT “Holiday cynics rejoice. Thanks to Holidate, we finally have our very own rom-com -- and it doesn't disappoint.” – Tell-Tale TV Oct 28, 2020 Full Review Christmas on Ice (2020) 2.5/5 EDIT “Chemistry can cure many stumbles within a fluffy romantic comedy, and Klein and Cooper have some, but not enough to save the film. Christmas On Ice also continuously undervalues its supporting storylines.” – Tell-Tale TV Oct 26, 2020 Full Review A Christmas Wish (2019) 4/5 EDIT “As for the story, it's so much fun!” – Tell-Tale TV Dec 2, 2019 Full Review A Sweet Christmas Romance (2019) 3/5 EDIT “As sweet as a sugar cookie.” – Tell-Tale TV Nov 11, 2019 Full Review Christmas Reservations (2019) 2.5/5 EDIT “Clever wordplay doesn't make a movie.” – Tell-Tale TV Nov 5, 2019 Full Review Christmas Pen Pals (2018) 4/5 EDIT “I can say with certainty that Christmas Pen Pals is at least a few steps above every other film I've seen in the genre.” – Tell-Tale TV Dec 17, 2018 Full Review The Christmas Contract (2018) 4/5 EDIT “It delivers the romance and happiness we are allowed to expect from this genre, without too much of the extra cheese or Santa that can sometimes be off-putting to a Grinch like me.” – Tell-Tale TV Nov 26, 2018 Full Review The Princess Switch (2018) 63% 4/5 EDIT “I find these twin-switch type movies fascinating when one actress is doing all of the work. I'm not saying Hudgens in a Netflix movie full of tropes is Emmy worthy, but it takes a lot of work.” – Tell-Tale TV Nov 19, 2018 Full Review
No Reviews Yet
Load More